What is a property tax grievance?
A grievance is the administrative review of your assessment, and the Department of Taxation and Finance says you must go through it before you can take the assessment to court. The Department is plain that "Assessors do not determine your property taxes," so a grievance is about the value on the assessment roll, not the rate.
The value under review is the one on the current tentative assessment roll, and the case you make is that it is too high.
Who can file a grievance, and does it cost anything?
The Department's grievance procedures page says any person who pays property taxes can grieve an assessment, including owners, purchasers and tenants who must pay the taxes under a lease or written agreement.
"There is no cost to grieve an assessment, and it does not require you to hire a lawyer," the Department says. You can fill out the form yourself, or authorize an attorney or other representative in writing on the form to file and appear for you.
A grievance firm is optional; if you hire one, read its agreement before you sign.
When is Grievance Day in Suffolk County?
Grievance Day is the day the Board of Assessment Review meets to hear complaints, and in most places it is also the filing deadline. The Department's grievance page, updated May 2026, says it falls on the fourth Tuesday in May in most of the state, but Suffolk County's town Boards of Assessment Review meet on the third Tuesday in May.
The town pages agree. Smithtown's Assessor says "Grievance Day is always the 3rd Tuesday of May each year." Brookhaven's Assessor took 2026 grievances from May 1 through the end of Grievance Day on May 19, 2026, online, by mail, by email or in a drop bin at Town Hall.
Confirm the date with your town assessor each spring. The Department says a missed deadline costs you both administrative and judicial review of that year's assessment.
How is Nassau County different?
Nassau County has a process of its own. The RP-524 instructions say "Nassau County has its own complaint form and procedures," and the Department's grievance page, updated May 2026, says the county's Assessment Review Commission meets throughout the year but complaints must be filed by March 1.
Nassau owners get forms, deadlines and instructions from the Commission, not from a town. Its deadline comes well before Suffolk's, so confirm the current dates with the Commission before relying on any guide, this one included.
Which form do I file in a Suffolk town or village?
Outside New York City and Nassau County, the form is RP-524, Complaint on Real Property Assessment, filed with the assessor or the Board of Assessment Review of the town where the property sits. Use a separate complaint for each separately assessed parcel, as the instructions advise.
A home in a village that assesses property has two assessments, one by the village and one by the town, and the Department says to file a separate RP-524 with each to grieve both. The village clerk can say whether the village assesses and when its board meets.
What evidence helps a grievance?
For most homes, recent sales of similar homes carry the most weight. The Department says "the best way to support your case is by providing sales of comparable properties where the sales prices are lower than the assessor's estimated market value of your property."
Part Two of the form also takes the purchase price if you bought recently, any recent offer for sale, a recent appraisal, a description of the buildings and their condition, and the cost of recent remodeling. Smithtown's Assessor also suggests an appraisal using the valuation date, which it says is usually the prior July 1.
Choose the value you ask for with care: the instructions warn that you may be held to the reduction you request, even if the facts would support a larger one. Steven and Rose can pull recent sales of similar homes near yours for you to review before you file.
What happens after the board decides?
You receive a notice of the board's decision with its reasons. On or before Grievance Day you and the assessor can instead sign a stipulation to a lower assessment on Part Six of the form, but then you cannot ask the board for more.
If you disagree with the decision, the next step is court review. Owners who live in their one, two or three family home can use Small Claims Assessment Review, which the Department describes as a low cost option for most homeowners. Other cases go to State Supreme Court as tax certiorari, where the Department recommends a private attorney.
The Department's grievance page, updated May 2026, says both must be started within 30 days of the filing of the final assessment roll, or of the notice of that filing, whichever is later.


