What does a seller pay at closing in New York?
Most of what a seller owes is paid out of the sale proceeds at the closing, so you rarely bring a check to the table. Your attorney's closing statement lists every charge, and which ones apply depends on your sale.
In most New York sales, the seller's side of that statement carries these lines:
- The New York State real estate transfer tax, which the law puts on the seller.
- The brokerage fee written in your listing agreement.
- Your own attorney's fee.
- The payoff of your mortgage, a home equity line or any other lien on the home.
- Adjustments with the buyer for property taxes and other charges already paid or still owed, plus any credit you agreed to in the contract.
What is the New York State transfer tax, and who pays it?
The state taxes the transfer of real property when it changes hands. The New York State Department of Taxation and Finance says the tax "is computed at a rate of two dollars for each $500, or fractional part thereof, of consideration." Your attorney works out the exact amount for your sale.
The seller pays it. The Department's instructions for Form TP-584 say the tax "is to be paid by the grantor (seller)" and is not payable by the buyer "except as provided in a contract between grantor and grantee." Unless your contract shifts it, the transfer tax sits on your side of the closing statement.
Form TP-584 is the return filed with the deed. Your attorney usually prepares it, and the tax is paid from the sale proceeds at closing.
What is negotiated rather than fixed?
The transfer tax rate is set by law. Most of the rest is set by agreement. The brokerage fee is set in your listing agreement, and it is negotiable: the New York State Department of State says "The commission or compensation of a real estate broker is not regulated by statute or regulation, therefore the amount and terms are negotiable." No law sets a standard rate.
Your attorney's fee is agreed between you and your attorney. Credits to the buyer, for example for something an inspection turned up, are agreed in the contract, and so is any change to who pays which smaller closing charges. Read the listing agreement before you sign it, and ask Steven or Rose what the fee covers.
What is different on the East End and in New York City?
Two more taxes on New York sales fall on the buyer, not the seller, so they do not appear on a seller's net sheet. New York's Tax Law section 1402-a says the additional tax it sets, known as the mansion tax, "shall be paid by the grantee," which is the buyer.
On the East End, Tax Law section 1449-aa defines the Peconic Bay region as "the towns of East Hampton, Riverhead, Shelter Island, Southampton and Southold," which takes in the North Fork, and section 1449-dd says the Peconic Bay region transfer tax "shall be paid by the grantee." Both laws also make the seller responsible if the buyer fails to pay or is exempt, so your attorney confirms who pays before closing.
In Queens and the rest of New York City, a sale also carries the city's own Real Property Transfer Tax. The New York City Department of Finance says "The tax is usually paid as part of closing costs at the sale or transfer of property." Its rates and forms are the city's, separate from the state's, so ask your attorney how it applies to your sale.
How do I get a net sheet for my home?
A net sheet is an estimate of what you keep after the sale: the likely price, less the transfer tax, the brokerage fee, your attorney's fee, your mortgage payoff and the adjustments. It is an estimate, and the closing statement at the closing is the final word.
To build one you need a payoff figure from your lender, the fee in your listing agreement, your attorney's quoted fee and a likely sale price. Steven and Rose will put together a net sheet for your home with each of these lines on it, and a home valuation gives the price line a starting point.


