Skip to main content

Selling

How Is a List Price Set for a House on Long Island?

A list price is set by comparing your home to similar homes nearby: recent sales, active listings, and homes that did not sell. We walk through the home, adjust the comparisons for condition, layout, and lot, then agree on a price and a plan at a pricing strategy meeting. The final decision is always yours.

By Updated 6 min readFiled under Selling

What is a list price based on?

A list price is where a seller and an agent agree to start the public conversation with buyers. It is not a bill, and it is not a promise of what a buyer will pay. It is a starting point built from evidence.

The evidence is a comparison. We look at what similar homes nearby have done and what buyers can see right now, then adjust for how your home differs. The assessor uses a similar comparison method for tax purposes: the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance explains that the assessor compares a property to similar properties that sold recently.

The same agency explains that market value is how much a home would sell for under normal conditions. That excludes sales that may be due to a relocation, a death in the family, or a divorce.

What happens at the walk-through?

Before any numbers, we see the home with you. A price on paper cannot tell us what a visit tells us, so the walk-through comes first.

Here is what we look at and ask about:

  • The condition of the kitchen, bathrooms, floors, roof, and mechanicals, as far as we can see them.
  • The layout: how the rooms connect, how many bedrooms and baths there are, and whether the floor plan matches how buyers tend to search.
  • The lot: its shape, its usable space, and anything that sets it apart, such as water access or a view.
  • Updates and repairs you have made, and any projects that were started and not finished.
  • Anything you want us to know that is not obvious from the street.

We also use the walk-through to point out the small fixes, cleaning, and staging choices that tend to matter most to buyers. We tell you honestly where spending money is unlikely to come back to you. Usually that means we are not asking for a big renovation.

What goes into the comparative market analysis?

The comparative market analysis is a side-by-side look at homes that are like yours. It uses three groups of homes, and each one tells us something different.

Recent sales

These show what buyers and sellers actually agreed to. We compare recent similar sales nearby to your home and adjust for the differences. We pick sales that are close to yours in type and location.

Active listings

These are your competition. A buyer touring homes will see them alongside yours, so we want to know what is on offer today and how it compares.

Homes that did not sell

These are easy to skip, and we do not skip them. A home that was listed and then came off without selling tells us something about what buyers did not accept. We look at what those homes had in common with yours.

Then we adjust the comparisons for condition, layout, and lot. A newer kitchen, an extra bedroom, or a larger lot can make one home a better or weaker match for yours, and we account for that rather than treating every nearby home as identical.

What is the pricing strategy meeting?

After the walk-through and the analysis, we sit down with you for a pricing strategy meeting. This is where the work turns into a decision.

We go through the recent sales, the active listings, and the homes that did not sell, and we show you how we adjusted each comparison. You can ask why a particular home is in the set or why another one is not. We would rather you question the comparisons now than wonder about them later.

Then we agree on a price and a plan together. The plan covers the preparation of the house, the photos and video, the marketing, and how showings and offers will be handled. If you want to see the full list, what a listing includes is laid out on our selling page.

The final decision is always yours. We give you our read and the reasons behind it, and you choose the price. There is no obligation to list after a walk-through and a pricing meeting.

How is this different from other estimates of value?

You may see several different numbers for your home, and they are not all doing the same job.

A tax assessment is built by the assessor for a different purpose, and it follows its own rules. The state explains how assessors work on its page about the roles of the assessor. It is not a list price.

A Broker Price Opinion is closer to what we do. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau describes it as an estimate of value provided by a real estate sales professional, most commonly used to justify a home's listing price.

Later, once you have an accepted offer, the buyer's side runs its own appraisal and mortgage process. That is a separate step, and what happens after you accept an offer in New York walks through it. Your lender handles the loan. Ask us for lender options and we will tell you how we know each one.

For questions about legal or tax details tied to your sale, confirm them with your attorney, lender, or tax professional.

What should you gather before the first meeting?

A little preparation makes the first visit more useful. You do not need to have everything in order, but it helps to have these on hand:

  • A list of updates and repairs, with approximate dates if you know them.
  • Any paperwork for additions, finished basements, or other changes to the house. Our post on the certificate of occupancy when you sell explains why that paperwork comes up.
  • Your own questions and your timeline.

To get started, request a home valuation with the form on our selling page, or call or text 631-213-2005, or email teamrivera@kw.com. Steven or Rose will reach out to set up a walk-through and a pricing strategy meeting. You can also reach us through our contact page.

Share this guide

Questions

Questions, answered.

More questions people ask about Team Rivera
Who makes the final call on the list price?
You do. We bring the comparisons and our reasoning, and we agree on a price and a plan together. The final decision is always yours.
Why do homes that did not sell matter?
A home that came off without selling shows what buyers did not accept. Looking at those homes alongside recent sales and active listings gives a fuller picture than sold homes alone.
Do I have to list after a walk-through?
No. Steven or Rose will set up a walk-through and a pricing strategy meeting with no obligation to list.
Should I renovate before I list?
Usually not a big renovation. We point out the small fixes, cleaning, and staging choices that tend to matter most to buyers, and we tell you honestly where spending money is unlikely to come back to you.

Get each guide by email, Tuesdays and Fridays.

Subscribe by email

Sources

Where this comes from.

Each source with the exact line we relied on and the day we read it. Confirm the details of your own sale or purchase with your attorney.

  1. 1.How to estimate the market value of your home - Tax.NY.gov

    New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read

    Market value is how much a property would sell for under normal conditions.
  2. 2.The roles of the assessor - Tax.NY.gov

    New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read

    The assessor compares a property to similar properties that sold recently.
  3. 3.I. Valuation standards - Department of Taxation and Finance

    New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read

    The sales comparison approach looks at recent sales of similar properties in the same area and adjusts them for dissimilarities.
  4. 4.Why did I receive different valuations during the mortgage loan application process?

    Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, read

    A Broker Price Opinion is an estimate of value provided by a real estate sales professional, most commonly used to justify a home's listing price.

Ask your own question

Talk to Steven and Rose.

Call, text, or send the form. Steven or Rose will get back to you with a straight answer for your situation.

Send us a note

Tell us a little about your plans. Steven or Rose will get back to you.

We use your details to reply to your request. See our privacy policy.