What is the New York mansion tax?
It is the common name for the additional real estate transfer tax in section 1402-a of New York's Tax Law. The state's regular transfer tax applies to most sales and is the seller's to pay. The mansion tax is a second, separate tax that applies only to homes, only from a set price up, and it falls on the buyer.
It covers more than houses. Tax Law section 1402-a counts any premises that "is or may be used in whole or in part as a personal residence," and names houses of up to three families, condominium units and co-op apartments. A condo or co-op purchase is treated the same way as a house.
What is the rate, and at what price does it start?
The New York State Department of Taxation and Finance says the tax applies to homes "where consideration is $1 million or more." Consideration is the legal word for the price. Because the Department's threshold reads "$1 million or more," a price of exactly that amount is included.
Tax Law section 1402-a sets the rate at one dollar of tax for every hundred dollars of "the consideration or part thereof attributable to the residential real property." The Department's own line, printed in the sources below, states the same rate. The rate applies to the price of the home, not only to the part above the threshold. When a property is partly a home and partly something else, such as a store, the tax is figured on the part that is residential.
Who pays the mansion tax, the buyer or the seller?
The buyer. The Department's technical memorandum TSB-M-19(1)R says "The mansion tax is required to be paid by the buyer (grantee)." Grantee is the legal word for the buyer, the person the deed conveys the home to.
Plan for it in the money you bring to closing, along with your down payment and your own closing costs. If you are shopping near the threshold, Steven and Rose will point it out when you set your price range, so the tax is part of your budget from the first showing.
When is the mansion tax paid?
At closing, together with the regular transfer tax. Tax Law section 1402-a says the tax "shall be paid at the same time and in the same manner as the tax imposed by section fourteen hundred two of this article," and section 1402 is the state transfer tax.
Your attorney handles the filing and tells you the amount to bring. The seller's attorney will also want to see it paid, for the reason in the questions below.
What counts toward the price?
The price for the whole property. Tax Law section 1402-a applies the tax when "the consideration for the entire conveyance is one million dollars or more," which is the total price for the property, not one part of it.
An existing mortgage you take over counts too. The Department's Publication 577 explains that for the regular transfer tax on some sales, a lien that stays on the property is left out of the price, but "This continuing lien deduction does not apply for the purposes of computing the additional tax imposed by Tax Law section 1402-a." If your contract includes anything unusual, such as items sold with the house or a credit from the seller, ask your attorney how it affects the price the tax is figured on.
How is it different from the seller's transfer tax?
They are two taxes on the same sale, paid by different sides. The state transfer tax applies to most sales, and the seller pays it unless the contract says otherwise; our guide to seller closing costs quotes its rate. The mansion tax applies only to homes at or above its threshold, and the buyer pays it.
Because each side pays its own tax, neither one shows up on the other side's closing statement in a normal sale. Your attorney lists the mansion tax on your side, with the other charges you pay at closing.
Is the tax higher in New York City?
Yes, for higher priced homes. Tax Law section 1402-b adds a supplemental tax on homes "within any city in this state having a population of one million or more" when the price is two million dollars or more, which in New York State means New York City, Queens included. The section sets its own rates in brackets that rise with the price, on top of the mansion tax.
If you are buying in Queens, ask your attorney early which of these taxes apply to your purchase and what they add to the money you need at closing.


